用戶:Hinnia/沙盒/History Notes (Leadership

出自合眾百科 Unitedbook
於 2024年5月1日 (三) 23:08 由 Hinnia對話 | 貢獻 所做的修訂 (建立內容為「== First Crusade Motivations == == First Crusade Leadership == === Leadership === * Certainly responsible for success * No single commander in chief * No kings * '''Henry IV''' and '''Philip I''' excommunicated * Princes from various parts of Europe === Initial Division === ==== Attitude towards Pope ==== * '''German''' and '''Lotharingians''' supporters of Henry IV * '''Raymond of Toulouse''' supported Pope ==== Attitude towards Alexius ==== * '''Ra…」的新頁面)
(差異) ←上個修訂 | 最新修訂 (差異) | 下個修訂→ (差異)

First Crusade Motivations

First Crusade Leadership

Leadership

  • Certainly responsible for success
  • No single commander in chief
  • No kings
  • Henry IV and Philip I excommunicated
  • Princes from various parts of Europe

Initial Division

Attitude towards Pope

  • German and Lotharingians supporters of Henry IV
  • Raymond of Toulouse supported Pope

Attitude towards Alexius

  • Raymond of Toulouse was happy to swear Allegiance
  • Bohemond did not wish to be subject to Alexius’s power

Attitude towards Power and Land

  • Bohemond and Tancred seeking land
  • Robert of Normandy seeking indulgence

First Wave: People’s Crusade

  • Peasants army led by Peter the Hermit and Walter Sansavoir
  • Caused a lot of trouble
  • Shipped across to Asia Minor within a week
  • Slaughtered by Kilij Arslan
  • Shows how terrible the crusade could have gone without good leadership even with a divided Muslim enemy

Council of Princes

  • If the crusade was to succeed
    • Had to overcome differences
  • Set hierarchical chain of command
    • Provided a forum in the absence of a single commander for decisions to be reached jointly
  • Took Nicea
    • With the help of Tacticius
  • Two wave strategy
    • Worked well
    • Suck up pressure from Kilij Arslan
  • Dorylaeum
    • Bohemond and Robert of Normandy attacked by the Turks
    • Two princes took up a defensive position
    • With the support of the second wave made the Turks retreat
    • Secures Asia Minor

Bohemond Leadership

Capture of Antioch

  • Foraging Strategy
    • Raymond foraged in Ruj Valley
    • Tancred in areas surrounding Harim
    • Ensured supplies
    • Helped them survive
  • Financial Support
    • Raymond of Toulouse was very wealthy
    • Used this money to help the Crusaders
    • Built La Mahomerie
  • Secret Negotiations
    • Negotiations with someone inside the city
    • Allowed access to Antioch
Secure of Antioch
  • Bridge Gate
    • Arranged for his troops to leavee
    • Kerbogha’s troops at other gates would not be able to reach him as the river blocked their path
  • 7 divisions
    • Each with a clear leader
    • Help keep the army in formation
    • Thinned out force of Kerbogha
    • While convincing Kerbogha that his army was not an all-out offensive
  • Kept back extra troops in a separate division
    • Rearguard
    • Stopped Kerbogha’s first relief force from supporting main force

Siege of Jerusalem

  • 5 weeks, rather than 7.5 months like Antioch
  • Tactical genius shown
  • Crusade leadership maintain unity to the end
  • Range of strategies
  • Siege tower to enter Jerusalem
  • Eastern wall (vulnerable)

Other factors

Popular pressure

  • Disagreements after the siege of Antioch
  • Crusade faced paralysis
  • Stopped for 6 months
  • Only because of popular pressure that the First Crusade continued

Muslim World

  • Divided into Shia and Sunni
  • Sunni would rather align with Crusaders against Shia and vice versa
  • Key Central Leaders died at the same time
    • Caused political fragmentation
    • By 1097-99 there was a power vacuum in Asia Miinor
  • Princes faced small rival lordships
  • Muslims failed to recognise the crusade as an army of religious conquest
  • Gave the Crusaders an advantage

Second Crusade Motivations

Second Crusade Leadership

Leaders

  • Eugenius has tight control of preaching
    • No peoples crusade
  • Proper Kings
    • Louis VII, the king of France
    • Conrad III, the king of Germany
    • State power and resources
  • Unified before heading to Outremer
    • Louis deliberately went with Conrad by land
    • Avoid antagonising Conrad
      • Conrad was in conflict with Scicily
    • In return Conrad offered fleet at Regensburg
  • Supposed to be successful
    • Not the case
    • Failure largely due to bad leadership

German Campaign (Octobebr 1147 to June 1148)

  • Departed with 8 days of supplies, estimating a 20-day journey
  • Assuming they could acquire supplies along the way
  • Plan did not go as expected
    • Overconfidence and the lack of control by Manuel I
  • The crusaders were ambushed by the Turks near Dorylaeum.
  • Retreat to Nicaea with a casualty rate of around 17 percent.

Failure to consult leaders of the crusader states

  • Did not consult with the leaders of Outremer (the Crusader states)
  • Initial goal: recapture Edessa
    • But was destroyed in 1146
    • Still had same goal in 1148 (Conrad letter)
    • Spent four months to establish new goal
    • Hindered progress into Outremer
    • Incurred additional expenses
  • Did not adequately respond to the needs of all the Crusader states
    • Antioch plam, which reflected northern interests
    • Jerusalem plan, which focused on the threat faced by the south
    • Decided to head south to Damascus
  • Contributed to delays and misalignment of objectives during the Second Crusade.

Siege of Damascus 1148

  • Began successfully
  • Attack by King Baldwin III's troops supported by Louis VII's soldiers.
  • Conrad III made significant gains
  • Goal was to attack the city walls and defeat the garrison
  • Changed their plan and attacked a weak point in the eastern walls.
  • Bad decision
    • No water or food
    • Exhaustion and retreat after three days.
    • Ended unsuccessfully.

Other factors

Muslim world

  • Far more untied
  • Much more powerful enemy when compared with first crusade
  • 1105: Al Sulami first preaches jihad
  • 1146 Nur ad-Din deployed Jihad

Lack of support from the Byzantines

  • First Crusade received support from the Byzantine Empire
  • Taticius sent to provide crucial guidance and support in battle.
  • Second Crusade Manuel I did not have good relations with the two kings
  • He did not provide the same support
  • Also had a treaty with the Turks
  • Betrayed the crusader’s location or plans for their enemy